Nigeria’s electricity market has recorded a $28.33m (N37.44bn) shortfall in ancillary service payments from international customers in Benin Republic and Togo, with Togo responsible for almost the entire outstanding amount.
The figures, obtained from NERC’s annual reports covering 2023 to 2025, indicate that three neighbouring countries — Niger, Benin and Togo — were billed a combined $183.5m for ancillary services during the period.
The services relate to the systems and market arrangements supporting electricity transfers from Nigerian generation facilities to the utilities serving customers in the neighbouring countries.
The three international customers are NIGELEC of Niger, SBEE of Benin and CEET of Togo.
Collectively, they paid $155.17m of the $183.5m billed, leaving about $28.33m unpaid.
The gap widened considerably in 2024, when the utilities paid $42.06m against a $56.04m bill, resulting in $13.98m in arrears.
The previous year recorded a $53.55m bill and $50.36m in payments, while the 2025 figures showed $73.91m billed against $62.75m paid.
CEET Accounts For $26.88m
A customer-by-customer breakdown shows that Togo has the largest outstanding obligation.
CEET accumulated charges of $50.38m but paid $23.5m, leaving $26.88m unpaid.
The figure accounts for roughly 95 per cent of the total outstanding debt attributed to the three utilities.
SBEE’s outstanding balance stood at $1.47m after it paid $44.71m against a $46.18m bill.
NIGELEC recorded no outstanding balance for the period, having paid $44.85m against charges of $44.84m.
The marginal excess payment by the Nigerien utility could have been applied to settle earlier obligations, according to the report.
Charges Separate From Electricity Cost
Energy sector expert Tobi Oluwatola said the debt should not be interpreted as the value of electricity consumed by the neighbouring countries.
Oluwatola, who is a partner at AP3 Advisory Services and chief executive of TAO Technologies, described the outstanding amount as a residual service charge covering several regulated functions within the electricity market.
He said the charges involve the regulator, transmission company, bulk trader, market operator and system operator and amount to about $20m per quarter.
According to him, the cost of the electricity itself, including energy and capacity charges for approximately 350MW, is settled through separate arrangements.
“The number in the news is the small administrative slice of the trade, and it happens to be the one layer not yet fully behind a guarantee. The neighbours pay this slice to the generating companies, alongside their energy and capacity charge; it is the generating company that pays the market operator.”
Oluwatola said the framework for international electricity transactions had been strengthened through the Eligible Customer reforms of 2017 and the Willing Buyer, Willing Seller framework introduced in 2019.
Under the arrangements, neighbouring utilities enter into bilateral agreements directly with Nigerian generating companies.
He said customers are required to provide financial security before electricity supply begins.
“To buy power this way, a customer must post a letter of credit or a bank guarantee to the market operator before a single megawatt flows. That is precisely why the energy trade with our neighbours works: it was designed to be commercially disciplined, and it runs on surplus capacity, not on power taken from Nigerian homes, and is capped at less than 10 per cent of the power on the grid.”
He said efforts were underway to apply similar safeguards to the ancillary service charges owed to the market operator.
According to him, delayed balances do not necessarily indicate a foreign government’s refusal to pay, as some cases may involve older government-linked generating plants operating under legacy arrangements during the transition in Nigeria’s electricity market.
We do everything possible to supply quality news and information to all our valuable readers day in, day out and we are committed to keep doing this.
Your kind donation will help our continuous research efforts.




















