Opposition parties and economic experts have challenged Finance Minister Taiwo Oyedele to provide evidence and explain the economic assumptions behind his warning that the naira could depreciate to N4,000 per dollar if the Federal Government restores petrol subsidy.
Oyedele reportedly made the projection during an interview on the sidelines of the recently concluded World Bank/International Monetary Fund meetings in Bangkok, Thailand.
His comments followed calls by some opposition figures, including African Democratic Congress presidential candidate Atiku Abubakar, Social Democratic Party candidate Adewole Adebayo and Nigeria Democratic Congress figure Peter Obi, for subsidy restoration to ease the economic hardship facing Nigerians.
The Allied People’s Movement (APM) questioned the government’s fuel pricing policy, alleging that the recent reduction in petrol prices amounted to a return of subsidy through the back door.
APM National Secretary Ayodele Adebayo also rejected Oyedele’s exchange-rate forecast, arguing that government policies had contributed to business closures and worsening economic conditions.
“What are they doing now with the current reduction in petrol price for one month? Is it not returning subsidy through the back door?” Adebayo asked.
He said the government should adopt an appropriate petroleum pricing framework that would prevent fuel costs from consuming workers’ earnings and household income.
The Nigeria Democratic Congress (NDC) also criticised the minister’s statement, describing it as a form of blackmail.
The party’s National Publicity Secretary, Osa Director, questioned why Nigeria’s refineries were not functioning effectively and alleged that crude-oil commitments linked to foreign loans had affected supplies to domestic refiners, including the Dangote refinery.
He argued that addressing problems in the petroleum sector could reduce the need for what he described as the minister’s “doomsday prediction.”
Experts Demand Evidence
Petroleum economist Professor Wumi Iledare said the debate over subsidy restoration should be guided by fiscal sustainability, market efficiency and measurable public welfare rather than political rhetoric.
He acknowledged that restoring subsidy could increase government spending, borrowing, foreign-exchange demand, fuel imports and opportunities for smuggling, depending on its design and scale.
However, he said the N4,000-per-dollar projection should be treated as a possible risk scenario rather than an inevitable outcome.
“The naira is influenced by foreign-exchange supply and demand, crude-oil receipts, domestic production, capital flows, reserves, monetary policy and investor confidence,” Iledare said, adding that the magnitude of any depreciation could not be established through assertion alone.
He also warned that subsidy removal should not be assessed solely by its fiscal benefits, noting that higher petrol prices affect transportation, food distribution, production costs and household welfare.
Iledare urged the government to disclose the cost and funding arrangements of any subsidy programme, identify its beneficiaries and establish safeguards against abuse. He also called for transparency over the use of savings from subsidy removal.
Economics and communications expert Clifford Egbomeade similarly said Oyedele should publish the assumptions and economic model underpinning the projection.
Egbomeade argued that the government should address exchange-rate volatility, domestic refining capacity and distribution costs rather than rely on blanket subsidies.
He added that any decision on subsidy restoration should consider its fiscal cost, effect on household purchasing power and implications for exchange-rate stability.
Economist and HighCap Securities Limited Managing Director David Adonri, however, said the minister’s forecast might not be an exaggeration.
Adonri argued that subsidy removal had improved government revenue distribution, reduced the need for public borrowing to finance fuel consumption and helped domestic petroleum production become more competitive.
However, he acknowledged that the policy had contributed to a severe cost-of-living crisis, blaming the government’s failure to implement effective supply-side measures in areas such as agriculture, mining, housing and alternative energy.
Atiku Attacks Tinubu Over Hardship
Meanwhile, Atiku criticised President Bola Tinubu’s defence of subsidy removal and his warning against returning to what he described as the country’s previous economic situation.
In a statement issued by his campaign’s Director of Strategic Communication, Phrank Shaibu, Atiku accused the President of being insensitive to the hardship caused by rising fuel prices.
He argued that Nigerians needed practical relief rather than political metaphors and proposed limited, budgeted support for verified petroleum products refined in Nigeria and sold locally.
Atiku said such a programme should exclude imported fuel and be monitored by independent auditors to ensure that any benefit reached consumers through lower prices.
He also criticised the administration’s handling of insecurity and police welfare, calling for improved salaries, healthcare and retirement benefits for serving and retired officers.
The Federal Government’s detailed response to the opposition parties’ criticisms and the experts’ demand for the assumptions behind the N4,000-per-dollar forecast was not contained in the report.
We do everything possible to supply quality news and information to all our valuable readers day in, day out and we are committed to keep doing this.
Your kind donation will help our continuous research efforts.




















